New York City could soon take a major step toward protecting crustaceans from a cooking practice animal welfare advocates have long criticized: boiling them alive.
A bill introduced in the New York City Council would prohibit restaurants from boiling live lobsters, crabs, and other crustaceans. Sponsored by Bronx Council Member Oswald Feliz and Manhattan Council Member Harvey Epstein, the proposal would require restaurants to kill the animals before cooking them. Under the proposed rules, restaurants would receive a warning for a first violation. Subsequent violations could result in civil penalties of up to $100 each.
Canva
In a memo accompanying the bill, its sponsors cite scientific studies indicating that crustaceans experience significant pain when boiled alive. They argue that New York City has a responsibility to prevent unnecessary animal suffering.
“Boiling an animal alive is the textbook definition of animal cruelty,” Feliz told the New York Post, pointing to the animals’ attempts to escape boiling water as evidence of distress.
The proposal follows similar animal welfare measures adopted in other parts of the world. Switzerland, Norway, and New Zealand have restrictions on boiling lobsters alive without first rendering them unconscious. The United Kingdom has also announced plans to prohibit the practice as part of its animal welfare strategy.
Pexels
Some restaurant owners, however, have pushed back against the proposal, arguing that the industry is already struggling with high operating costs and that the City Council should prioritize other concerns. Retired restaurateur Angelo Vivolo called the measure “idiocy” in comments to the New York Post, while Hamptons chef Zach Erdem said it could influence his plans to open a Manhattan restaurant.
The legislation is still under consideration and has not passed. If enacted, the crustacean measure would add New York City to a growing international effort to reconsider how animals commonly served as food are handled and killed.

New York City takes on animal welfare
The proposal arrives amid a series of high-profile animal welfare debates in New York City. On Nov. 19, Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed legislation banning horse-drawn carriages, giving the industry until June 2028 to wind down. The law also includes protections intended to prevent the horses from being sold for slaughter or transferred to other carriage businesses.
At the same time, the city’s restaurant scene has faced criticism over its relationship with animal products. Eleven Madison Park, which made headlines for going entirely plant-based in 2021 before returning animal products to its menu, has drawn renewed backlash for promoting a chicken dish stuffed with foie gras. Acclaimed chef Alexis Gauthier criticized the move, arguing that the restaurant’s influence could help legitimize a product associated with significant animal suffering.
Together, these developments highlight the ongoing debate over how New York City treats animals, from the streets to restaurant kitchens. As lawmakers consider new protections for crustaceans, the question of what constitutes acceptable treatment of animals remains firmly on the city’s agenda.
For more plant-based stories like this, read:
JUMP TO ... Latest News | Recipes | Guides | Health | Subscribe







